Indian military operation along Burma border opens new rift with Pakistan
Renewed animosity between nuclear rivals who have fought two major
wars over the border territory of Kashmir risks undermining attempts at
co-operation
Tim Craig and Annie Gowen for the Washington Post
Tuesday 16 June 2015 05.36 EDT
An Indian military operation
along its eastern border with Burma has Pakistani leaders rattled,
resulting in threats of swift retaliation should India ever try similar
manoeuvres along its western border with Pakistan.
The Pakistani statements – which include provocative reminders that
India is not the only subcontinent power with nuclear arms – are once
again exposing the deep-rooted suspicions and lingering potential for
conflict between the longstanding rivals despite groundbreaking outreach
to ease tensions.
It has been worse. The two countries have fought three major wars
since 1947, engaged in a nuclear arms race in the 1980s and clashed in
the 1990s. But the current uneasiness underscores the challenges for
leaders on both sides seeking to overcome the rifts and shift to shared
issues, such as regional economic cooperation, water resources and the
rise of militant factions.
Over the past month, Pakistani
leaders have accused India of sponsoring terrorist attacks inside
Pakistan and slandering it at international forums. Historical
grievances also have been dusted off, such as claims that India helped
force the loss of Pakistani territory – which would become Bangladesh –
more than four decades ago.
Indian leaders, in turn, have
been outraged by a Pakistani court decision in April to grant bail to
Zaki-ur-Rehman Lakhvi, the alleged mastermind of the 2008 Mumbai
terrorist attacks. Lakhvi was a commander in the Lashkar-e-Taiba, a militant group that has historical ties to Pakistan’s intelligence agency.
Now, the downturn in relations even includes open speculation in
Pakistan about the possibility of a cross-border strike by India. Such
worries – even though apparently remote – carry added resonance between
countries that have troops facing each other in the disputed Kashmir
region.
“This is going to need more diplomatic and political efforts to lessen the tension.”
“This is coming back to 1980s levels,” said Muhammad Amir Rana, an
Islamabad-based security analyst, referring to a period when both
countries ramped up efforts to develop nuclear arms. “This is going to
need more diplomatic and political efforts to lessen the tension.”
That tension intensified last
week after Indian special forces conducted an operation to pursue rebels
accused of killing 18 Indian soldiers earlier this month. Indian media has reported that those forces crossed the border into Burma, where they killed more than 50 militants.
Both the Indian army and the Burmese government have denied that
Indian troops crossed the border. In a newspaper interview, however,
India’s information minister, Rajyavardhan Rathore, said Indian forces
had pushed deep into Burma. He called the operation a “message” to
countries such as Pakistan that it will not hesitate to pursue threats
outside of its borders.
“We will strike when we want to,” Rathore, a retired army officer, told the Indian Express newspaper.
The reaction from Pakistani leaders has been swift and severe –
touching off a wildfire of social media comments on both sides of the
border.
In a statement issued last Wednesday, Pakistani interior minister
Chaudhry Nisar Ali Khan warned Indian prime minister Narendra Modi to
think twice before threatening Pakistan. “Those who are contemplating
any kind of adventure in Pakistan must know that they will get a bloody
face in the process,” Khan said. “Those who have evil designs against us
– listen carefully, Pakistan is not Burma.”
Pakistan’s defence minister, Khawaja Asif, even brought up the
possibility of nuclear war should India ever launch a similar incursion
into Pakistan. He urged the international community to intervene,
telling Geo News the latest tension could prove a “harbinger of
disaster” for South Asia.
Pakistan’s army chief, Raheel Sharif, chaired a meeting of his top
commanders last Wednesday to discuss Pakistan’s worsening relationship
with India. Over the past month, Pakistani leaders have repeatedly
accused India’s intelligence agency, the Research and Analysis Wing
(Raw), of sponsoring several recent terrorist attacks in Pakistan.
Indian leaders, meanwhile, have
repeatedly accused the Pakistani intelligence agency of fueling
discontent in Indian-controlled Kashmir while also supporting terrorist
groups. Earlier this month, Bloomberg News reported that India’s
minister of state for defence, Rao Inderjit Singh, is even worried that
Islamic State militants could obtain a nuclear bomb from Pakistan.
Speaking at a Delhi event last Thursday, India’s defence minister,
Manohar Parrikar, declined to discuss specifics of the Burma operation,
but said that “those who fear India’s new posture have already started
reacting”.
“You have seen for the last two to three days, a simple action
against insurgents has changed the mindset of the full security scenario
in the country,” Parrikar said.
Parrikar last month raised hackles in Pakistan by saying at a closed
event that India would “neutralise” terrorists with terrorists – remarks
he later said were taken out of context.
In a statement last Wednesday after the commanders’ meeting,
Pakistan’s military said it has taken serious notice of “Indian hostile
rhetoric coupled with covert and overt actions to destabilise Pakistan”.
Pakistani military leaders “reiterated its resolve to defeat their
designs and defend the territorial integrity of Pakistan at any cost
with a befitting response”, the statement said.
Since Pakistan was partitioned from India in 1947, the two countries
have fought three major wars, two of them over the disputed border
region of Kashmir. The last major war, in 1971, occurred when India’s
military supported a rebellion in East Pakistan. Pakistani forces were
resoundingly defeated, resulting in East Pakistan becoming the
independent nation of Bangladesh.
Earlier this month, during a two-day visit to Bangladesh,
Modi lashed out at Pakistan and accused it of “harbouring” terrorists and becoming a regional “nuisance”.
He also implied that India covertly orchestrated the Mukti Bahini
rebellion in East Pakistan that sparked the 1971 war that led to an
independent Bangladesh, according to Indian media reports. Those remarks
infuriated Pakistani leaders, who viewed them as an intimate swipe,
considering they were made on Bangladeshi soil.
Even a year ago, there were high hopes both in Delhi and Islamabad
that Modi and Pakistan prime minister Nawaz Sharif could achieve a
breakthrough in diplomatic relations. After he was elected to a third
term as prime minister in 2013, Sharif pledged he would work to bolster
trade ties with India.
Sharif’s efforts angered the Pakistani military, which has limited
Sharif’s ability to follow through on the that pledge. Still, after his
election last spring, Modi invited Sharif to attend his inauguration.
Sharif accepted, becoming the first Pakistan prime minister in history
to attend such a celebratory event in India.
Since then, however, relations between the two countries have soured.
Beginning last summer and lasting through January, there were several
major skirmishes between the two armies along the contested border.
Sporadic gunfire was also reported on the border last Thursday.
Meanwhile, social media on both sides reflected support of their
leaders and militaries. Indians showed support for Modi through the
Twitter hashtag of #56inchrocks, a reference to a past claim by Modi
about his chest size.
In Pakistan, the most popular Twitter hashtag is #atankWadiIndia, which is a slur that refers to India as being a terrorist.
“Our travel advice to Modi is to send his soldiers to invade Pakistan
with their bodybags, they’ll need them, and we don’t have any,” the
group @defencepk, which tracks the Pakistani military, tweeted to its
69,000 followers.